For decades, scientists who studied early modern humans believed that our ancestors initially inhabited only small areas of Africa, the savannas of the eastern and southern part of the continent, and then moved north into Asia, Europe and beyond. In this view, early humans bypassed West and Central Africa, especially tropical forests. These areas, the argument went, were populated much later.
LOADING
Share
Researchers say multiple groups of early modern humans intermingled and spread across Africa, not just in small areas in the east and south, before moving to Europe and Asia.
But now, a growing group of researchers has cast doubt on this narrative. Working in Senegal, Cameroon, Malawi and elsewhere, they are uncovering evidence that early humans spread across much more of Africa before venturing elsewhere. This work has moved the field beyond the old out-of-Africa narrative and is transforming our understanding of how multiple groups of early modern humans intermingled and spread across the continent, providing a more nuanced picture of our species’ complex origins.
“It’s becoming more and more clear that humans didn’t originate in a single population in one region of Africa,” says Eleanor Scerri, an archaeologist at the Max Planck Institute of Geoanthropology in Jena, Germany. “If we really want to understand human evolution, we need to look at all of the African continent.”
Quiver trees in the Northern Cape of South Africa; the wood is used by local hunter-gatherer groups there to make quivers for small, poison-tipped arrows. (Brenna Henn)
Most researchers agree that early modern humans emerged in Africa between 200,000 and 300,000 years ago. About 60,000 years ago, they spread to other parts of the world. Until recently, though, most experts thought these humans populated West and Central Africa, especially the tropical forests there, only within the past 20,000 or so years.
For some researchers, this narrative made little sense. “Humans like to move around a lot,” says University of Pennsylvania geneticist Sarah Tishkoff, who has been working to unravel Africa’s deep genetic lineage for more than two decades. “They had this beautiful continent, they could move all over, go to different niches, with different resources.”
The reason no one found evidence of early human settlement in West and Central Africa, Scerri and others say, is that few people had looked there. For many decades, most researchers tended to focus on low-hanging fruit — areas of the continent where fieldwork was less difficult. Because the climate is dryer and cooler in East and South Africa and the terrain is more open, fossils are easier to find and date. Most of West and Central Africa is hot and humid, so bones and DNA degrade more quickly. In addition, that region can be a challenging place to work, not only because much of it is thickly forested, but also because some areas are enmeshed in long-running and chaotic conflicts.
Yale University paleoanthropologist Jessica Thompson is shown working at the Hora 1 site in Malawi. (Jacob Davis)
Some research suggests that cultural bias may also have played a role. “Most research has been spearheaded by people from the global North,” says Yale University paleoanthropologist Jessica Thompson. “And their perspective is, ‘Well, we want to know how people got out of Africa, to where we come from.”
As a result of all these factors, most scientists have focused largely on sites in South and East Africa. This has contributed to the idea that early modern humans primarily inhabited these regions. Frustrated that the academic establishment didn’t take their ideas seriously, a few researchers began trying to uncover evidence that supported their views. Over the past decade or so, they’ve found it.
Last year, a group that included scientists from Senegal, Europe and the United States reported that modern humans had lived at a site on the coast of Senegal 150,000 years ago. Previous estimates put the earliest human habitation in West Africa at 30,000 years ago.
Moreover, the site was in a mangrove forest, rather than the typical grassland or sparse savanna usually associated with early-human habitation. Scerri says her latest research in Senegal, not yet published, may push this date back even further. “It’s clear that there were different people in different places doing different things,” she says. “And they were there for a long time. A lot longer than we realized.”
Another study, from 2022, analyzed DNA from the bones of 34 people who lived across sub-Saharan Africa between 5,000 and 18,000 years ago. Examining such ancient DNA is important because it offers a much clearer window onto the structure of more ancient African populations. The research showed that from 80,000 to 20,000 years ago, populations that had been fairly isolated from one another began to interact across large swaths of the continent. These links spanned thousands of miles, from Ethiopia, through Central African forests and down to South Africa.
“People were clearly moving quite broadly across Africa,” says Thompson, one of the study’s co-authors. “They were not staying in these little isolated populations.”
And a paper published four years ago in Nature examined the remains of two children found at a rock shelter in Cameroon, in the western part of Central Africa. One of the children lived 3,000 years ago, while the other lived 8,000 years ago. The researchers, from Harvard and other institutions, managed to collect DNA from the two — the first ancient human DNA ever sequenced from Central Africa. They detected four separate human lineages between 60,000 and 80,000 years ago, including a previously unknown lineage — what they called a “ghost population” — that probably lived in West Africa. The results provide more support for the idea that humans have been in West Africa for far longer than previously realized and adds to the evidence that humanity’s roots exist across more than one region of Africa.
Experts say it’s important to note that close relatives of modern humans — Neanderthals, Homo erectus and several other species — had already spread beyond Africa to Europe and Asia, in some cases millions of years ago. But these groups contributed relatively small amounts of DNA to the modern human lineage.
A drone’s-eye view of Jessica Thompson’s excavation at the Hora 1 site in Malawi. The site had two of the oldest human skeletons in Africa to preserve ancient DNA. The remains have ancestry showing widespread genetic admixture across all of eastern and central Africa. (Jacob Davis)
Because it can be so difficult to find fossils and retrieve ancient DNA in many parts of Africa, scientists have had to develop innovative approaches to establish early-human habitation. For instance, Thompson and her colleagues studied sediments around Lake Malawi in the northern part of the country. Over thousands of years, the lake shrank and grew, depending on the amount of rainfall. During wetter periods, the number of trees around the lake would expand significantly.
But Thompson found that during a wetter period starting 80,000 years ago (and continuing today), the number of trees did not increase nearly as much as expected. Instead, the scientists found an abundance of charcoal. Thompson says this shows that humans were living in the region, perhaps in fairly large numbers, and were burning wood on a significant scale, either to modify the environment for hunting or to cook or keep warm — or all three.
A key aspect of this new understanding is the Pan-African hypothesis: Scerri and others argue that modern humans probably evolved from the intermingling of different groups from a range of areas of the continent. “There were a number of modern human populations living in different regions of Africa, and we emerged over time from the complex interactions between them,” Scerri says. “Basically, we’re a mix of a mix of a mix of a mix.”
In research published last year, University of California at Davis population geneticist Brenna Henn and her colleagues examined the genomes of almost 300 Africans from across the continent. By analyzing and comparing the genetic data, they were able to construct a model for how humans originated within the continent over the past several hundred thousand years. They found that modern humans descended from at least two distinct populations who lived in different parts of the continent. She and her colleagues are now analyzing genomes from 3,000 people, mostly Africans but also people of African descent who live elsewhere, as well as Indigenous Americans and others.
Scerri has also found evidence to support the Pan-African idea. She has shown that Middle Stone Age culture persisted in West Africa until quite recently, less than about 11,000 years ago. This culture, a particular way of making stone tools, disappeared much earlier in other parts of the continent, 30,000 to 50,000 years ago. This is important, she says, because it is precisely what the Pan-African theory predicts: “In this model, you’d expect that each region would have its own distinctive cultural trajectory, due to periods of isolation. This research shows how this was possible.”
Not everyone is convinced. Richard Klein, a paleoanthropologist at Stanford University who has spent decades studying early modern human origins and migration in Africa, says, “I don’t understand the evolutionary mechanism behind” the pan-African origins theory.
Pontus Skoglund, a population geneticist at the Francis Crick Institute in London who has collaborated with Scerri, says that the Pan-African idea is plausible, but that he isn’t fully persuaded. “To me, it also seems possible that a large portion of present-day people’s ancestry might be found in a single region,” he says. “But we don’t know.” He says there is still “a lot of uncertainty” about who was where and when.
Scerri agrees that more research is needed. But after years of fighting skepticism, she says she feels vindicated that the new perspective has caught on. “Right now, this is such an exciting area to work,” she says. “It’s really an incredible story, one that’s emerging before our eyes.”
Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/
Previous Article
Chinese Counterterrorism in Africa
Next Article
Family of killed Nigerian protester demand justice
